Greg Smith, who covers the Midwest and national recruiting for Rivals, invited me to collaborate on his Fact or Fiction column for this week, and the question that we pondered was an interesting one.
Fact or Fiction: Michigan State has an opportunity to capitalize on the latest twists in the Michigan cheating scandal.
I thought about this for a while and while there could absolutely be an "opportunity" for Michigan State to leverage based on the imminent punishment coming down for Michigan at some point due the Connor Stalions illegal scouting scandal, I did not not feel that it would be anything significant.
The general thought from experts is that vacated or forfeited wins are unlikely for Michigan. Also, because Michigan is not accused of using ineligible players as far as we know, it feels very unlikely that U-M’s national title from the 2023-2024 season is going to be taken away. So, what is most likely going to happen? In my opinion, Michigan gets a hefty fine and Sherrone Moore gets hit with a show-cause penalty and maybe is suspended for a couple of games.
Earlier today, we saw former
Michigan head coach Jim Harbaugh get hit with a four-year show-cause penalty and a one-year suspension if he were to return to the college game, but that was for COVID dead period recruiting violations and is somewhat irrelevant now that he is in the NFL, as is any discipline handed down for the other former staffers involved who are no longer with U-M. We'll see what happens to Harbaugh, Moore, Stalions and Michigan's football program when the punishments are actually handed out for the cheating allegations (who knows how long it will take).
So, maybe Moore is suspended for the Michigan/Michigan State game in 2024, but there isn't much likely to change on the field as players are not expected to be suspended. And it's unclear what, if any recruiting restrictions come out of this. If they're hefty, maybe that helps Michigan State win a couple of in-state/Midwest kids over Michigan, but U-M has usually been a stronger recruiter at the national level, so I don't see a big difference there either, even those penalties were applied.
I also don't get the feeling that Jonathan Smith and his staff are too worried about what is going on in Ann Arbor as they work to build their own program in year one at Michigan State
Ultimately Greg and I both felt that the answer is fiction.
Read our full thoughts on as to why here:
Four-star offensive lineman Nicolai Brooks is down to a final three of Alabama, Georgia and Texas.
michiganstate.rivals.com
What is your opinion?